Nvidia’s Colette Kress inherits a crisis. Does a glass cliff for women apply?

This post first appeared in the St. Louis Business Journal.

Colette Kress has stepped into one of the world’s most closely watched jobs.

When Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s CEO, the board named Kress, the company’s CFO since 2013, interim chief executive and credited her with helping lead the company's extraordinary growth.

In this new role, she will lead Nvidia through a crisis she didn’t create.

 
 

Based on her impressive leadership track record, Kress is a logical choice. Her appointment is also an opportunity to examine a phenomenon researchers have debated for two decades.

It’s called the glass cliff. The term describes the idea that women who break through the glass ceiling are more likely to land in roles that are precarious from the start.

In a 2005 study, psychologists Michelle Ryan and Alex Haslam looked at board appointments at Britain’s largest companies.

Findings showed that during a market downturn, the companies that appointed women to their boards had typically been struggling for months beforehand. Organizations that named men had been relatively stable. In other words, the women didn’t cause the decline. They were brought in during it.

Their later analysis suggests that when companies struggle, people may “think crisis, think female.”

The research on business settings is still mixed. Even so, high-profile cases keep it in the conversation: Mary Barra at General Motors, Marissa Mayer at Yahoo, and Jane Fraser at Citigroup all took on challenging roles at the time.

It would be easy to read this as boards setting women up to fail, but these appointments can arise from subtle processes, sometimes even well-intended ones, rather than overt bias alone.

Nvidia’s situation fits the authors’ broader definition of a crisis, which includes a dramatic blow to a company’s reputation.

 
 

Huang has said he doesn’t believe in succession planning, and The Wall Street Journal reported on Nov. 9 that the board had not publicly named a successor. Whether a confidential emergency plan existed, we may never know; boards often keep those private.

Elevating a trusted CFO after a sudden departure is a sound governance decision. It’s also a common one: CFOs often step in as interim CEOs.

The risk comes from the circumstances surrounding that choice. An abrupt exit, an ongoing investigation, and a market watching every move have created an unusually difficult situation. In Kress’ case, that pressure is intensified by chipmaker Nvidia’s reach across the global economy and the national security questions surrounding it.

How she was chosen matters less than how she’ll be judged. Leadership scholars have long noted that people tend to credit or blame leaders personally for company results, overlooking the context around them.

For women in these roles, Ryan and Haslam argue, that tendency can cut deeper: Compared with men, they face a greater risk of being scapegoated for problems that started before they arrived. Earlier studies of senior women found that they often held less authority and had fewer support networks than men. When results are tough, an old story may take over. The outcome gets read as a verdict on women leading, not on the situation they were handed.

None of this means women leaders are beyond scrutiny. CEOs should be held accountable for the decisions they make. The glass cliff simply asks that women in these roles be judged against the conditions they inherited, not as though they started from solid ground.

One detail from that first, smaller study stands out: The companies that appointed women during the downturn saw their share prices climb afterward.

Kress’ record shows she’s more than qualified. The question the glass cliff raises isn’t whether a woman in this situation can lead. It’s whether the system around her is built to help her win.

As Ryan and Haslam put it, “opportunity is not the same as equal opportunity.” The next time a woman is handed the top job at the hardest moment, it’s worth noticing the circumstances as much as the leader.

 

Interested in style psychology, regular styling advice and shopping recommendations?

Sign up for my weekly Style / Substance newsletter…


 
Next
Next

The Most Versatile Strathberry Bags